Premier’s office refuses demands from all fronts for an external review of ‘ethnicgate’

Published: March 7, 2013


Ben Chin

Communications Director for the Office of the Premier, Ben Chin, pictured here with Premier Christy Clark, says there is ‘no need’ for an external review as the issue at hand is ‘whether civil service resources were appropriately managed’ and the head of the civil service is ‘the appropriate person’ to determine that. Darryl Dyck/CP

The Office of the Premier continues to reject demands to launch an external review into the “ethnicgate” scandal, despite some of the requests coming from within the B.C. Liberal party itself.

“It’s just a joke for the legal system and for the assembly that … your junior (Deputy Minister to the Premier John Dyble) investigates you,” B.C. Liberal party member Vikram Bajwa told Vancouver Desi. “Nothing concrete is going to come out of this.”

The John Dyble investigation will be the beginning of the end (of the party).”

Bajwa, along with the NDP and B.C. Conservatives, are asking caucus for an external review into the government strategy leaked last week aimed at wooing ethnic votes in the run-up to the May election. In addition to offering ethnic groups apologies for historical wrongs as a means of gaining “quick wins,” the strategy sought to use taxpayer money for partisan purposes.

Vancouver-Fraserview MLA Kash Heed believes a review should be conducted the same way police investigate internal incidents, referencing external bodies like the Office of the Police Complaints Commission or the Independent Investigation Office.

“I’m asking for a transparent, accountable and appropriate investigation done in a timely fashion,” Heed said. “Certainly the perception that comes from the bureaucrat doing it is not a good one.”

The NDP party has been demanding the same since they leaked the document last week.

“We’re going to have a peripheral review by the Deputy Minister — who was appointed by Christy Clark,”said opposition House Leader John Horgan. “(And) Mr. Dyble has no power to subpoena.”

According to Horgan, Dyble cannot compel people who have left the government, like Kim Haakstad or Brian Bonney.

“He has no ability to interview them if they choose to not participate,” he said. “I hold him in the highest regard — he’s just the wrong person in the wrong place to do this investigation.”

“It’s a mess and the solution requires independence … then the public would be guaranteed that we would get to the bottom of this.”

B.C. Conservative leader John Cummins agrees, adding the review puts Dyble in an “awkward position.”

“The problem, of course, is that there is that relationship to the government — him being a senior bureaucrat . . . and essentially investigating his boss,” he said.

Both Bajwa and Horgan believe a B.C. judge would be fit to lead the investigation.

“There are no shortages of judges on various benches in British Columbia that would be impartial,” said Horgan.

But according to communications director for the Premier’s Office, Ben Chin, there is “no need” to follow up on any of these suggestions.

“What we are looking at here is whether the civil service resources were appropriately managed,” he said. “There’s no better person to do that than the head of the civil service.”

“(Dyble) is the appropriate person to review it and we should await the release of the review.”

Dyble’s review is expected to be released by the end of next week.

But Bajwa still wants an alternative.

“Otherwise … (Christy Clark) is going to take everybody down the drain with her,” he said.

He not only wants to question the premier, her staff and the concerned ministers, but he also wants to look into the Times of India Film Awards, which he believes was another ruse to gain ethnic votes.

“We love the movie stars from India, but how (did this) happen?” he asked. “The questions are not for British Columbia, it’s for the multicultural groups, the ethnic groups who have been damaged and who have been disrespected.”

“Unfortunately (Clark) doesn’t see the big picture.”

Tags: , , , , , , , ,



Surrey whiz-kid awarded $80,000 scholarship for his leadership skills

TEREZA VERENECA SURREY NOW CONTRIBUTOR  SURREY — A Surrey whiz-kid known for his leadership skills is being recognized by the Seymour Schulich Foundation with an…
Continue Reading »


Man-eating leopard targets drunk Indian villagers

VANCOUVER DESI Villagers in northern India are afraid to go out after dark because of a man-eating leopard they believe is targeting drunks as they…
Continue Reading »

girl child

Upset over having two daughters and no son, man bobbitises himself

IANS Patna – A man in Bihar has bobbitised himself, sniping off his penis with a sharp knife in a fit of rage after a…
Continue Reading »


B.C. teachers and employers hold marathon bargaining session over weekend

THE CANADIAN PRESS VANCOUVER — Representatives for B.C.’s public school teachers and their employers bargained through the weekend in another effort to resolve the strike…
Continue Reading »

New Aga Khan museum and Ismaili complex opens in Toronto

@ THE CANADIAN PRESS TORONTO — The first museum in North America devoted to Islamic art will help promote an understanding of a religion that…
Continue Reading »

Key players in B.C.’s teachers’ strike quietly resume discussions

By Tamsyn Burgmann THE CANADIAN PRESS VANCOUVER — Chief negotiators were quietly hunkered down for talks as another week without school loomed on the horizon…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

underwater photos

Gallery: Couples pose for ‘romantic and beautiful’ underwater photos

VANCOUVER DESI Some memories need to be captured in the most beautiful and romantic settings, especially when it comes to life’s important occasions involving weddings…
Continue Reading »

crime-Reeva Steenkamp

South Africa prosecuting authority unhappy with Oscar Pistorius judgement in shooting death of his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp

IANS Pretoria – South Africa’s top prosecuting authority Friday expressed its disappointment on not being able to secure a conviction on the original charge of…
Continue Reading »

Indian Designer Shravan Kumar

Hyderabad’s Kumar showcasing ‘best fabrics in India’ in return to Vancouver Fashion Week (w/gallery)

LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI In comparison to fashion weeks in Toronto and New York — which showcase locally-based designers — Vancouver Fashion Week stands out…
Continue Reading »


Toronto to open Aga Khan Museum featuring Islamic art and culture, first of its kind in North America

PETER KUITENBROUWER THE NATIONAL POST Luis Monreal is a ball of energy who speaks quickly and wields a large vocabulary. Born in Spain to a…
Continue Reading »

Vancouver Fashion Week

Vancouver designer’s new collection inspired by tragic collapse of clothing sweat shop in Bangladesh

LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI As a young and budding fashion designer in Vancouver, 23-year-old Taran Cheema is conscious of the controversies surrounding her industry. “I…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood Latest

Parineeti Chopra and Aditya Roy Kapur

Gallery: Bollywood actors Aditya Roy Kapur and Parineeti Chopra on ‘food yatra’

IANS New Delhi – The lead actors of “Daawat-e-Ishq” Aditya Roy Kapur and Parineeti Chopra have embarked on a ‘food tour’ to promote their upcoming…
Continue Reading »

Shah Rukh Khan Deepika Padukone Bollywood sex

Salman Khan: Shah Rukh Khan and Happy New Year team will promote film on ‘Bigg Boss’

IANS Mumbai – Actor Salman Khan, who is gearing up with “Bigg Boss” season 8 says his rival Shah Rukh Khan will promote his film…
Continue Reading »

Salman Khan

Salman Khan’s ‘hit and run’ trial to resume from Sep 24

IANS Mumbai – Following the production of the “missing” case papers in the Salman Khan hit-and-run case, the trial against the actor will resume before…
Continue Reading »