Alleged terrorist plotters failed to recruit Ontario pathologist, says his lawyer

Published: April 3, 2014
Canada-Pakistan-Ontario

Khurram Syed Sher arrives to face trial on a terrorism charge at the Ottawa court house in Ottawa on Monday, February 10, 2014.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

JIM BRONSKILL
THE CANADIAN PRESS

OTTAWA — A lawyer for accused terrorist Khurram Syed Sher says there is no evidence his client signed on to a purported conspiracy to support violent jihad.

During closing arguments Thursday, defence lawyer Michael Edelson told an Ontario Superior Court judge that Sher did not “buy in” to the scheme of two alleged co-conspirators.

Secret audio surveillance of a July 2010 discussion among the three men at an Ottawa home reveals no intent on Sher’s part to become part of a plot, Edelson said.

“He didn’t buy in. He didn’t join,” Edelson said. “There was never an actual objective — which he agreed to — that was illegal.”

The Crown says the homegrown group was dedicated to supporting violent jihad by whatever means possible.

It contends the three men agreed to raise money, send cash abroad, take paramilitary training, make and use explosives, and scout targets in Canada.

Sher, 31, has pleaded not guilty to a charge of conspiring to facilitate terrorism.

He was an anatomical pathologist in St. Thomas, Ont., south of London, before his arrest in August 2010.

Sher made international headlines shortly after his arrest when it emerged he had once performed on the popular TV program “Canadian Idol.” He has been out on bail, under strict conditions, for years.

A publication ban on certain elements of the case limits what can be reported during the trial, expected to wrap up Friday.

Early in the trial, the Crown played six segments of sometimes patchy audio culled from electronic surveillance of the 2010 meeting.

At one point Sher and the two others on the recording discuss the best means of choosing a group leader, suggesting they pick a name from a hat or even spin a bottle.

The meeting descends into laughter, farce and “all sorts of stupidity,” Edelson told the court.

“They weren’t legitimately creating any conspiracy here.”

There is “ample proof” that the other two men had been plotting together, but that happened before Sher dropped in on them that evening en route to southern Ontario, Edelson said.

During the meeting, the three discussed various plans, allegedly including Sher’s intention to arrange tactical instruction through a man he met in Pakistan who claimed to be with the Taliban.

Edelson said the Crown has acknowledged that the RCMP looked into the Pakistani man’s background and concluded he was not known to be affiliated with any terrorist group.

The evidence indicates Sher was simply “trying to string these guys along” during the Ottawa meeting and actually had no serious intention of becoming an extremist.

In his closing arguments, Crown prosecutor Jason Wakely said the accused co-conspirators were candid with Sher about their past activities and future plans. For instance, one confided to Sher that he learned to make bombs in Afghanistan.

The three men were clearly talking about advancing their cause through violent means, Wakely said.

Judge Charles Hackland raised the question of whether Sher suddenly found himself, quite unexpectedly, in the middle of some “very radical talk.”

Wakely said the audio recording of the July 2010 meeting clearly implicates Sher.

“He is agreeing to this objective to facilitate violent jihad,” Wakely said. “He knew what they were all about. He knew what they were doing.”

Sher never expresses any reservations, nor says anything to distance himself from the two others, he added.

No reasonable person would have kept silent about what they heard that night, Wakely said.

“How can you not call the police?”

Follow @JimBronskill on Twitter

17:58ET 03-04-14

[+]

Tags: , , , , , , , ,



Readers Comments (0)

Comments are closed.

Featured

crime-British Columbia

Three arrested after Surrey RCMP-involved shooting in Newton

AMY REID SURREY NOW NEWTON — Three people are in custody following a police-involved shooting in Newton Friday afternoon. Shortly after noon, plainclothes officers attempted to…
Continue Reading »

Immigrant-language test

Woman loses Canadian citizenship for failing language, knowledge tests after it was granted in error

ADRIAN HUMPHREYS POSTMEDIA NEWS A would-be Canadian who received a grade of zero out of six on her citizenship language test and four out of…
Continue Reading »

India-Kashmir-Obama

Pakistani PM Sharif asks Obama to play role for resolution of Kashmir issue

MUNIR AHMED THE ASSOCIATED PRESS ISLAMABAD — Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif on Friday asked the U.S. President Barack Obama to play a role in…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

crime-British Columbia

Three arrested after Surrey RCMP-involved shooting in Newton

AMY REID SURREY NOW NEWTON — Three people are in custody following a police-involved shooting in Newton Friday afternoon. Shortly after noon, plainclothes officers attempted to…
Continue Reading »

Whitecaps2

Spice Sports: Whitecaps announce new USL PRO team!

GOPI AND THE GORA FOR VANCOUVER DESI An exciting announcement was made this morning at UBC’s Gerald McGavin Rugby Centre. Soccer fans in Vancouver will…
Continue Reading »

Immigrant-language test

Woman loses Canadian citizenship for failing language, knowledge tests after it was granted in error

ADRIAN HUMPHREYS POSTMEDIA NEWS A would-be Canadian who received a grade of zero out of six on her citizenship language test and four out of…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

desi bride loaded in gold

Indian bride draws flak for wearing $700,000 jewellery at her wedding

CEN AGENCY An Indian sweet maker made sure his daughter was the golden girl at her upcoming wedding by covering her in gold jewellery worth…
Continue Reading »

India

Video: Bear mauls Indian farmer to death, injures second man (Warning: Graphic Content)

VANCOUVER DESI An Indian farmer was mauled to death and another left seriously injured after a terrifying and unusual bear attack in Karnataka on Monday,…
Continue Reading »

Spiderman

Video: India’s real-life Spiderman scales buildings with bare hands

VANCOUVER DESI A 27-year-old man in India who is nicknamed the “real-life Spiderman” has become one of Karnataka’s leading tourist attractions for his ability to effortlessly…
Continue Reading »

desi victim

Victim of ski accident to open spinal-cord recovery centre in Richmond (w/video)

NICK EAGLAND VANCOUVER DESI Dhruv Kapoor realized he was in deep trouble as he barrelled down a ski run in Russell, Man., on an icy…
Continue Reading »

op-ed

Aziza Sindhu: How do you grieve for a tyrant father?

AZIZA SINDHU CALGARY HERALD My father, Salim M. Sindhu, passed away on Nov. 10. As a child, I wished he smiled at me, as a…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

Bollywood

Aamir Khan and Deepika Padukone the next hit Bollywood couple?

HINDUSTAN TIMES Bollywood actors Aamir Khan and Deepika Padukone are known to deliver hits on their shoulders alone. Now, audiences may be in for a…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood sex video

I can’t take nonsense: Sonakshi Sinha on why she lashed out at KRK on Twitter (w/gallery)

HINDUSTAN TIMES Some Bollywood stars tend to be diplomatic about controversies, and choose not to react. Sonakshi Sinha isn’t one of them. Last month, she…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood wedding reception

Photos: Khan-tastic wedding reception for Salman’s sister Arpita

VANCOUVER DESI While celebrities have reached the wedding reception for Salman Khans sister Arpita and businessman Aayush Sharma to wish them their best, photos have…
Continue Reading »