Indian state government to compensate two women for illegal detention over Facebook post

Published: July 15, 2014
Illegal detention

India’s Human Rights Commision has directed Maharashtra government to compensate two women for illegal detention over their Facebook post. AP Photo/Matt Rourke, Facebook

IANS

Mumbai – The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) Tuesday sent a reminder to the Maharashtra government to pay Rs.50,000 each as compensation to two women who were illegally detained for 10 days by police following a Facebook post after the death of Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray two years ago.

In a communication to the Maharashtra chief secretary, the NHRC reiterated that “their detention was in violation of the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed in the Constitution”.

It ordered compliance of its order within four weeks along with proof of payment, failing which the NHRC would resort to a coercive process.

The reminder came in the Nov 19, 2012 case in which the NHRC took suo motu cognizance after the two 21-year-old women from Palghar town in Thane were arrested.

The women – Shaheen Dhada and Renu Shrinivasan – had lamented in a Facebook post the virtual paralysis in the state Nov 18 when Thackeray’s funeral was held in Mumbai.

While Shaheen had posted the comment, her friend Renu had ‘liked’ it, angering Shiv Sena leaders who vandalized a hospital run by Shaheen’s uncle.

Police arrested both the women Nov 19 though they had already removed the post and even apologized for it the same day.

After an inquiry, the NHRC observed that it found no malicious intention in the comments to hurt the feelings of any class or religion.

“The comment only indicated that the bandh was not necessary as a mark of respect to the departed leader and that the city was shut down due to fear and not due to respect,” the NHRC said.

From the facts in the case, the NHRC said police had no reasonable ground to invoke Section 505(2) of the Indian Penal Code that charges people with issuing statements amounting to public mischief, with intent to cause fear or alarm.

“Because of the over-reaction of the police, these two young women had to be in jail for more than 10 days for which the state is prima facie responsible,” it said.

The NHRC said every citizen can interpret these comments as per his/her thoughts. However, these did not have any content to attract provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000.

As per Article 19 of the Constitution, every individual has the right to freedom of expression, which is a Fundamental Right and therefore, their arrest was a serious violation of human rights, it concluded.

IANS 2014-07-15 20:48:03

[+]

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,



Readers Comments (0)

Comments are closed.

Featured

prakash2

Indian news channel hires country’s first transgender anchor

VANCOUVER DESI A 31-year-old transgender woman in India has become the country’s first-ever transgender person to read the news on live television, according to the…
Continue Reading »

notinmyname1

Young Muslims in Britain speak out against ISIS with social media campaign

VANCOUVER DESI Muslims in Britain are speaking out against the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) with a social media campaign to raise awareness…
Continue Reading »

ER_-_BIBI_ESCORT_2_218008286

Deported Saskatoon woman in hiding in Pakistan, friend says

CHARLES HAMILTON and EVAN RADFORD POSTMEDIA NEWS and THE CANADIAN PRESS Jamila Bibi, the refugee claimant deported this week from Saskatoon, is now in hiding in Pakistan,…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

Today on the Hill: Duffy could have trial date set

By Terry Pedwell THE CANADIAN PRESS OTTAWA — Canadians will get a better idea today of when disgraced Sen. Mike Duffy will go on trial…
Continue Reading »

Maternal health in, climate change out: A look at Canada’s changing UN speeches

By Alexander Panetta THE CANADIAN PRESS UNITED NATIONS — A scan of Canadian speeches at the United Nations General Assembly reveals a shift in priorities…
Continue Reading »

ER_-_BIBI_ESCORT_2_218008286

Deported Saskatoon woman in hiding in Pakistan, friend says

CHARLES HAMILTON and EVAN RADFORD POSTMEDIA NEWS and THE CANADIAN PRESS Jamila Bibi, the refugee claimant deported this week from Saskatoon, is now in hiding in Pakistan,…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

Larissa Cahute

Video: Vancouver Desi reporter gets a ‘desi’ makeover

VANCOUVER DESI Vancouver Desi reporter Larissa Cahute gets a taste of the hectic life backstage at Vancouver Fashion Week as she gets done up in…
Continue Reading »

banned-desi

Surrey’s Punjabi radio stations facing CRTC ban

TERESA VERENCA SURREY NOW SURREY — Two radio stations operating out of Surrey could be slapped with mandatory cease-and-desist orders come October. According to the…
Continue Reading »

DEPORTED-PAKISTAN

Rally held in Saskatoon in support of 65-year-old woman deported to Pakistan

THE CANADIAN PRESS SASKATOON — Supporters of a 65-year-old woman who was deported to her native Pakistan earlier this week have held a rally at…
Continue Reading »

Designers-entertainment

Fashion over the years in Bollywood

IMROZ MAUR VANCOUVER DESI Bollywood and Fashion go hand in hand; there is no Bollywood without fashion and there is no fashion without Bollywood. They…
Continue Reading »

Little India

Death of a neighbourhood? Little India’s Punjabi Market struggles to survive

GORDON MCINTYRE VANCOUVER DESI When Simran and Hardeep Virk met 20 years ago at Langara College, they’d go to All India Sweets & Restaurant for…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

Indian film star Vivek Oberoi walks with his wife Priyanka Alva Oberoi on the green carpet as they arrive for 15th annual International Indian Film Awards Saturday, April 26, 2014, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara)

Why did Vivek Oberoi refuse a role on American series Homeland?

HINDUSTAN TIMES While Bollywood actors often jump at the opportunity to collaborate on international projects, Vivek Oberoi wasn’t quite so fortunate. Although the actor was…
Continue Reading »

Indian actress Aishwarya Rai Bachchan is one of the members in Sanjay Gupta's upcoming star-studded movie Jazbaa. Aishwarya poses here at the amfAR 21st Annual Cinema Against AIDS during the 67th Cannes Film Festival in southern Franc on May 22, 2014. ALBERTO PIZZOLI/AFP/Getty Images

Sanjay Gupta to add more stars to upcoming Bollywood film Jazbaa’s cast

IANS Mumbai  – Filmmaker Sanjay Gupta is excited about the way his next project Jazbaa, starring Aishwarya Rai, Irrfan Khan and Anupam Kher, is shaping…
Continue Reading »

Indian Bollywood film actress Priyanka Chopra poses during a promotional event of the Tata Salt 'Maine Desh ka Namak Khaya Hai' campaign, which features the story of boxer Mary Kom, and the promotion of the film 'Mary Kom' in Mumbai on September 10, 2014. AFP PHOTOSTR/AFP/Getty Images

Priyanka Chopra accepts Hrithik Roshan’s dare, performs handstand in heels

IANS Mumbai — Priyanka Chopra accepted and performed a handstand with a push up – a dare thrown at her by Hrithik Roshan. “The only…
Continue Reading »