Jury to decide whether Kelowna drug dealer Joe Verma killed Brittney Irving in cold blood

Published: October 16, 2013
Brittney Irving

Jury to decide whether Brittney Irving (L) was killed by Joe Verma (R). RCMP handout.

KELOWNA DAILY COURIER

Twelve jurors were behind closed doors Tuesday night to consider whether Joe Verma murdered Brittney Irving in cold blood.

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Allison Beames spent the morning reviewing the five-week trial and posing five questions the men and women must all answer yes to before they can convict the Kelowna drug dealer of first-degree murder as charged. The first question will probably take them the longest — did Verma kill her?

The case against the 32-year-old is a circumstantial one with no direct evidence against him, the judge said. The jury must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that he was the gunman who ended Irving’s short life more than three years ago.

The prosecution argues Verma convinced Irving he was willing to buy at least 50 pounds of high-grade marijuana from her for more than $100,000. He knew she was hungry for cash to pay a lawyer after police busted her grow-op a week earlier.

People close to Irving, 24, testified she was making numerous deals to acquire pounds of marijuana in the days prior to her disappearance. On April 6, 2010, Verma asked her via text message whether she had “that 50-cent CD” — a cryptic reference to the quantity he requested, the Crown said.

Verma lied that he was at his cousin Jason Labonte’s house all that day and later told him to “shut up” about it to police, said prosecutor Iain Currie. In fact, Verma arranged with Irving to go shooting in the woods after she delivered the weed. When the truck he borrowed got stuck in the mud there, he asked Labonte to help pull him out.

Verma’s friend Mike Roberts testified he loaned his truck to Verma that morning because Verma didn’t want to be seen driving his own truck. Roberts identified a pair of gym shoes and a hunting jacket found on Irving’s body as his belongings, which he stored in his truck.

Verma told him he’d replace them. He later ordered Roberts to take the blame for Irving’s death and promised to set up his wife financially while he was in jail, Roberts said.

Labonte and Roberts are both under police protection and entered the courtroom through a door reserved for the judge and court staff.

The defence says the jury must consider Irving’s criminal lifestyle and the bad company she kept. It’s impossible to be sure what the text messages between her and Verma mean, and many witnesses who gave evidence have criminal records.

Labonte and Roberts both lied to police and gave testimony that defied common sense, said lawyer Jordan Watt. There’s no forensic evidence linking Verma to the body, Irving’s SUV or to Roberts’s truck. And the lack of animal activity on the body, which police found near Big White three weeks after she disappeared, suggests she was killed long after April 6.

The jurors must acquit if they find Verma did not kill Irving. If they agree he did, they must be unanimous that he did it on that day in or near Kelowna. If satisfied, they must then consider whether he killed her with a firearm. A pathologist testified the four gunshot wounds in her torso were fatal.

The fourth question concerns whether the gunman intended to kill her. The two wounds in Irving’s back suggests she was upright. The two in her front had sharp, upward trajectories, the judge said.

The jury must say yes to all questions before reaching the fifth — was the killing planned and deliberate? To find Verma guilty of first-degree murder, he must have devised the plot and not fired the gun on impulse. If the jurors can’t agree, Verma is guilty of second-degree murder, Beames said.

The deliberations began shortly after 2 p.m. Tuesday.

Related Stories:

Read more Okaangan news at kelownadailycourier.ca


Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,





Featured

surgery wait times

Surrey Memorial tops surgical wait times exceeding one year, could be fined for backlog of bookings

ADRIAN MACNAIR SURREY NOW  METRO VANCOUVER — Fraser Health could face $2.5 million in fines over a backlog of surgical wait times in hospitals across the…
Continue Reading »

"There is No Honour in Violence Against Women" Campaign

MOSAIC tackles ‘honour-based’ violence against women and girls (w/video)

LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI Non-profit immigrant settlement agency MOSAIC B.C. launched a campaign Friday to raise awareness about ‘honour-based’ violence against women and girls. The…
Continue Reading »

Social Responsibility

Surrey Food Bank’s annual open house to show off renovations

SURREY NOW  ‘Tis the season, and the Surrey Food Bank is kicking things off with its annual open house. Set for this Saturday (Nov. 29),…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

surgery wait times

Surrey Memorial tops surgical wait times exceeding one year, could be fined for backlog of bookings

ADRIAN MACNAIR SURREY NOW  METRO VANCOUVER — Fraser Health could face $2.5 million in fines over a backlog of surgical wait times in hospitals across the…
Continue Reading »

BC teachers strike-politics

Christy Clark throws support behind Amrik Virk taking ethical fire

NDP insists B.C. premier should fire advanced education minister for helping bypass provincial pay rules while on board of Kwantlen University ROB SHAW POSTMEDIA NEWS  VICTORIA…
Continue Reading »

Football

Hard work paying off for North Surrey junior bantams

PATRICK JOHNSTON VANCOUVER DESI It’s championship weekend all across B.C., and another group of hardscrabble youth have a tale of their own: the junior bantam…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

BC teachers strike-politics

Christy Clark throws support behind Amrik Virk taking ethical fire

NDP insists B.C. premier should fire advanced education minister for helping bypass provincial pay rules while on board of Kwantlen University ROB SHAW POSTMEDIA NEWS  VICTORIA…
Continue Reading »

FASHION-PAKISTAN-AAMNA-AQEEL

Gallery: The bold and beautiful strut their stuff at Pakistan Fashion Week

VANCOUVER DESI Pakistan’s bold and beautiful models presented the Autumn/Winter 2014 collections at the three-day long Fashion Week in Karachi. The Pakistan Fashion Week has…
Continue Reading »

Black-Friday-Sale-1

Coupon Queen: Tips for Surviving Black Friday Mania

RUBY BEDI BAINS VANCOUVER DESI You may be planning on crossing the border to head to the US but take note Canadian retailers have embraced…
Continue Reading »

murder-British-India

South African judge will decide whether to throw out honeymoon murder case

CHRISTOPHER TORCHIA THE ASSOCIATED PRESS JOHANNESBURG — A South African judge will rule Dec. 8 on whether to dismiss the murder case against a British…
Continue Reading »

Surrey-crime-stats

Surrey mom who lost her daughter to a drunk driver calls for tougher laws

TOM ZYTARUK SURREY NOW SURREY — Dare to know how many times police in B.C. issued Immediate Roadside Prohibitions for impaired driving over the past…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

Salman Khan's sister Arpita's wedding

Bollywood actress Sonakshi Sinha rubbishes reports of teary tiff with Salman Khan at Arpita’s wedding

HINDUSTAN TIMES On Thursday (November 27), a report suggested that Sonakshi Sinha was reduced to tears at Arpita Khan’s wedding reception after an alleged argument…
Continue Reading »

Irrfan Khan

Bollywood’s Irrfan Khan already in talks for another project with Steven Spielberg after Jurassic World

HINDUSTAN TIMES While he has proven his acting prowess in Hindi films time and again, Irrfan Khan is also, perhaps, India’s best-known export to the…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood movie

Ungli: Relevant and Timely, ‘Ungli’ fingers the corrupt (w/trailer)

SUBHASH K. JHA IANS  Film: “Ungli”; Cast: Sanjay Dutt, Emraan Hashmi, Randeeo Hooda,Kangna Ranaut, Neel Bhoopalam, Angad Bedi, Neha Dhupia; Directed by Rensil d’Silva; Rating:…
Continue Reading »