Komagata Maru descendants demand apology from Canada

Published: January 11, 2013

LARISSA CAHUTE
VANCOUVER DESI

Crowded deck of the Komagata Maru in 1914. Submitted photo/Leonard Frank, Vancouver Public Library

After the Punjab government acknowledged the “unsung heroes” of Komagata Maru, Indo-Canadians are at a loss as to why Canada refuses to do the same.

Punjab Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal announced in Chandigarh, India Thursday that those involved in India’s freedom struggle, including martyrs of the 1872 Kuka movement, Komagata Muru in 1914 and 1919 Jallianwala Bagh massacre, will be recognized and their families likely compensated.

“Coming from the Punjab government … it’s great news,” said Surrey resident Jaswinder Singh Toor whose grandfather was one of hundreds of Indians aboard the Japanese chartered ship en route to Vancouver. “(But) financial (compensation) is not that important for us, what is more important is the recognition.”

“All we’re asking for is an apology in (Canadian) Parliament.”

Toor’s grandfather was hoping for a better education in Canada until the ship was turned away from the Burrard Inlet May 23, 1914 and forced back to Calcutta where British forces fired on them, killing 22 people.

“It was terrible unhealthy conditions (onboard),” Toor told Vancouver Desi. “And more than 20 were killed and the majority of them, including my grandfather were put in the jail and (forced to work) hard labour (for years).”

When finally released, his grandfather devoted the “rest of his life” to the freedom movement, but was forever tainted from the experience.

“At that time there was a lot of racism and the community felt unwelcome,” Toor said. “My uncle asked my grandfather to come and join him (in Canada in 1969), my grandfather refused – he said that once that country humiliated him and his fellow passengers that he does not feel like going back.”

Surrey MP Jasbir Sandhu has been fighting for nearly 20 years for recognition in the House of Commons.

Sandhu labeled Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s apology to the Surrey community at a festival in Bear Creek Park in 2008 as “fake” and “clearly rejected by the community.”

Monument to the Komagata Maru was unveiled along the seawall near Convention Centre West in Vancouver, B.C., on July 23, 2012. Steve Bosch/PNG

“If he can (apologize) in a park well why not in the House of Commons?” asked Sandhu. “The community has signed a number of petitions over the years asking the federal government to officially and respectfully close this chapter so the healing process can begin of this terrible dark chapter in our history.”

“We need to recognize our past wrongs … this is about doing the right thing.”

Toor believes the South Asian community deserves an apology in the same way it was given to First Nations for residential schools and the Chinese community for the Chinese Head Tax.

“There’s more meaning for us in an apology in the House of Commons,” said Toor. “It is on record … it’s more coming from the heart.”

Not only would it recognize “the struggle and the pain,” but it would also serve as a lesson for the younger generations.

“They will be proud of their elders and their culture and how hard their fathers or grandfathers or great grandfathers had to fight for their rights,” he said.

lcahute@theprovince.com
twitter.com/larissacahute


Tags: , , , , , , , , ,





Featured

Sikhs to quit Trudeau's Liberals

Sikhs ‘across Canada’ to jump Trudeau ship

Nominations issue: ‘We are not Liberals, that’s for sure,’ says general secretary of Vancouver temple LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI A large group of Sikhs in…
Continue Reading »

TK

Vancouver accountant pins hopes on civil action against newspaper publisher he says attacked him

LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI A Vancouver accountant is upset that a prominent South Asian newspaper publisher he accused of attacking him won’t go to trial….
Continue Reading »

Taliban attack

Surrey’s Pakistani-Canadians to hold candlelight vigil at Holland Park for children massacred in Taliban attack

SURREY NOW NORTH SURREY — Hundreds of people are expected to turn out at Holland Park in Surrey tonight to hold a candlelight vigil in…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

Sikhs to quit Trudeau's Liberals

Sikhs ‘across Canada’ to jump Trudeau ship

Nominations issue: ‘We are not Liberals, that’s for sure,’ says general secretary of Vancouver temple LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI A large group of Sikhs in…
Continue Reading »

TK

Vancouver accountant pins hopes on civil action against newspaper publisher he says attacked him

LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI A Vancouver accountant is upset that a prominent South Asian newspaper publisher he accused of attacking him won’t go to trial….
Continue Reading »

Taliban attack

Surrey’s Pakistani-Canadians to hold candlelight vigil at Holland Park for children massacred in Taliban attack

SURREY NOW NORTH SURREY — Hundreds of people are expected to turn out at Holland Park in Surrey tonight to hold a candlelight vigil in…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

Taliban attack

Letter: A Canadian mom mourns for victims of the Taliban school attack

SPECIAL TO VANCOUVER DESI At the loss of young dreams, an appeal to the parents of this world: While we always talk about how the…
Continue Reading »

India-Canada

B.C. Premier Christy Clark hopes her son will learn life lessons on India school-building trip

THE CANADIAN PRESS KELOWNA, B.C. — British Columbia Premier Christy Clark says she’ll be heading to India with her son on Boxing Day to help…
Continue Reading »

Indian followers of deceased guru Ashutosh Maharaj Divya Jyoti Jagriti Sansthaan sit front posters bearing his image at a stall during a congregation at his ashram ahead of a High Court hearing to discuss his possible cremation in Nurmahal some 30kms from Jalandhar on December 14, 2014. Ashustosh Maharaj was declared clinically dead on January 2014 but his body has been kept in a deep-freeze at his ashram with followers confident he will return to life to lead them. STRSTR/AFP/Getty Images

Indian court rules frozen dead guru can remain in deep freezer – for now

VANCOUVER DESI An Indian court has delayed the cremation order of a dead guru whose been kept in a deep freezer by his followers since…
Continue Reading »

apology

Ottawa quietly apologized to India after Canadian forces appeared at Surrey event that ‘glorified terrorists’

PETER O’NEIL POSTMEDIA NEWS Canada apologized to India in 2011 after a ministerial inquiry confirmed that military personnel had participated at a Remembrance Day event that “glorified terrorists”…
Continue Reading »

rape anniversary

Photos: New Delhi protests violence against women ahead of 2nd anniversary of India gang rape

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS People in New Delhi put on a street play Monday to create awareness about violence against women during a protest ahead of…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

Sexy posters Bollywood

Gallery: Bollywood’s sizzling film posters in 2014

VANCOUVER DESI Bollywood actor Aamir Khan became the hot topic of discussion on social media after stripping onscreen for the first time for his film…
Continue Reading »

desi babe

Gallery: Hottest new faces in Bollywood 2014

VANCOUVER DESI The young and the restless are stirring up the calm world of Bollywood this year, ruled mostly by the three Khans and a…
Continue Reading »

shiamakdesi

Gallery: Santa goes Bollywood at Shiamak’s Winter Funk in Surrey

VANCOUVER DESI Bollywood choreographer Shiamak Davar’s Winter Funk rocked Surrey last week with its Christmas themed matkas and jhatkas. Shiamak’s spokesman Rajesh Mansukhani told Vancouver Desi…
Continue Reading »