CORRUPTION: NRI Canadian citizens falling victim to ‘land mafia’

Published: January 10, 2013

LARISSA CAHUTE
VANCOUVER DESI

Surrey resident Kamaljit Thind has been fighting to maintain the property rights of his land in India for the past two years.

Since Thind moved to Canada in 1991, the value of his agricultural land has “increased so much,” but many repairs are needed.

“(My distant relatives) live over there (and) they want to occupy that land, (but) they don’t want to give us (rent),” he said. “They always refuse.”

With little help from the government or police, Thind’s brothers traveled to India in an attempt to make the needed repairs to a water pump and get the rent they’re owed.

But Thind is just one of thousands of Non-Resident-Indians struggling with real estate and property rights issues.

India Overseas Congress president is demanding the Canadian government help NRI Canadian citizens with their property rights. Photo by: Les Bazso, PNG

According to Vikram Bajwa, Indian Overseas Congress president, more than 1,800 cases like Thind’s — and worse — exist and are backlogged in Punjab court.

“That’s a heavy number,” Bajwa told Vancouver Desi, adding the overall value adds up to about $350 million.
Over the past ten years this has been an increasing trend as NRIs become “new Canadians.”

“Because the population is growing, the land value in Punjab … it has gone ten fold,” said Bajwa.

So either distant relatives or real estate agents who keep watch on vacant land of migrated owners, known as the “land mafia,” seize the property while they’re gone.

Bajwa blames the “corrupt bureaucracy and the corrupt police.”

“Our government in India has failed to protect our properties back there because we live (in Canada),” he said. “Once we go back there we are in a different law. We are foreigners … because we acquired Canadian citizenship.”

“But we are originally from India … we (shouldn’t) be treated as second class citizens.”

Another “major dilemma” is the Canadian Embassy in New Delhi doesn’t have a department to handle the real estate aspect of IndoCanadians in India, said Bajwa, leaving NRIs to go “through this rigamarole” on their own.

So Bajwa wrote a letter on Tuesday asking Minister of Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism, Jason Kenney, who is currently in India, for help.

Minister of Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism Jason Kenney. Photo by CP.

“We seek your assistance to take up the matter with Chief Minister S.Parkash Singh Badal … our High Commission in New Delhi, should be instructed to assist the Canadians, who are facing issues, concerning the “rights and ownership” associated with real estate,” he wrote in the letter.

Local immigration lawyer, Richard Kurland, sees one problem with the request, though.

According to Kurland, there’s been an increasing trend in new immigrants failing to claim foreign assets to the CRA.

And Bajwa admit many NRIs are afraid to come forward because of this.

“The value has increased exponentially — that’s a capital gain that must be reported in Canada,” said Kurland.

But regardless of the infraction, Kurland believes the government should still step in.

“Canada still has a diplomatic and political obligation to assist Canadians who apparently are being targeted on the basis of being Canadians,” he said. “Even if some of these individuals don’t necessarily have clean hands when it comes to disclosure of their status overseas.”

But according to an emailed statement from the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, “property disputes are private legal matters” and property in India — even if owned by Canadians — “is subject to Indian law.”

But Bajwa believes with government help, foreign investments will get reported, thus bringing money in to the CRA.

But if the current system remains, it will only continue to “deter people from going back (to their homeland),” said Bajwa. “About eight years ago, you could say, ‘OK, I have my retirement home in India,’ but not anymore because of this.”

lcahute@theprovince.com
twitter.com/larissacahute


Tags: , , , , , , , , ,





Featured

Dr. Rohit Joshi, chairman of Aarna Superspecialty Hospital in Gujarat.

Newborn Indian baby has tail – that was his parasitic twin – removed

VANCOUVER DESI An Indian baby born with a 350 grams, 12-cm ‘tail’ on his back has had it removed just five days after birth, according…
Continue Reading »

tiger attack

White tiger kills young man who climbed into animal’s moat-surrounded enclosure at Delhi zoo (Warning: Graphic Video)

MUNEEZA NAQVI THE ASSOCIATED PRESS NEW DELHI — A white tiger killed a young man who climbed over a fence at the New Delhi zoo…
Continue Reading »

Mars Orbiter Mission MOM

Indian spacecraft MOM on course to orbit Red Planet, aims to explore Martian atmosphere

KATY DAIGLE THE ASSOCIATED PRESS NEW DELHI — India will soon know if its first interplanetary mission will achieve its goal, when a spacecraft built…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

Today on the Hill: Duffy could have trial date set

By Terry Pedwell THE CANADIAN PRESS OTTAWA — Canadians will get a better idea today of when disgraced Sen. Mike Duffy will go on trial…
Continue Reading »

Birth, maternal care

Maternal health in, climate change out: A look at Canada’s changing UN speeches

ALEXANDER PANETTA THE CANADIAN PRESS UNITED NATIONS — A scan of Canadian speeches at the United Nations General Assembly reveals a shift in priorities during…
Continue Reading »

ER_-_BIBI_ESCORT_2_218008286

Deported Saskatoon woman in hiding in Pakistan, friend says

CHARLES HAMILTON and EVAN RADFORD POSTMEDIA NEWS and THE CANADIAN PRESS Jamila Bibi, the refugee claimant deported this week from Saskatoon, is now in hiding in Pakistan,…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

All Women's jirga

Pakistani women making history – fighting for rights using Jirga

SUNNY MANGAT VANCOUVER DESI Pakistani women making history –fighting for rights using Jirga. A Jirga is essentially a community council that is made up of…
Continue Reading »

PNG_0920N_BARINDER_RASODE_MAYORAL_ANNOUNCEMENT_218072244

Q & A: Surrey mayoral candidate Barinder Rasode discusses upcoming campaign trail

LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI After months of speculation, Surrey city councillor Barinder Rasode finally confirmed her bid for mayor in the upcoming election at a…
Continue Reading »

Larissa Cahute

Video: Vancouver Desi reporter gets a ‘desi’ makeover

VANCOUVER DESI Vancouver Desi reporter Larissa Cahute gets a taste of the hectic life backstage at Vancouver Fashion Week as she gets done up in…
Continue Reading »

banned-desi

Surrey’s Punjabi radio stations facing CRTC ban

TERESA VERENCA SURREY NOW SURREY — Two radio stations operating out of Surrey could be slapped with mandatory cease-and-desist orders come October. According to the…
Continue Reading »

DEPORTED-PAKISTAN

Rally held in Saskatoon in support of 65-year-old woman deported to Pakistan

THE CANADIAN PRESS SASKATOON — Supporters of a 65-year-old woman who was deported to her native Pakistan earlier this week have held a rally at…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

Indian film star Vivek Oberoi walks with his wife Priyanka Alva Oberoi on the green carpet as they arrive for 15th annual International Indian Film Awards Saturday, April 26, 2014, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara)

Why did Vivek Oberoi refuse a role on American series Homeland?

HINDUSTAN TIMES While Bollywood actors often jump at the opportunity to collaborate on international projects, Vivek Oberoi wasn’t quite so fortunate. Although the actor was…
Continue Reading »

Indian actress Aishwarya Rai Bachchan is one of the members in Sanjay Gupta's upcoming star-studded movie Jazbaa. Aishwarya poses here at the amfAR 21st Annual Cinema Against AIDS during the 67th Cannes Film Festival in southern Franc on May 22, 2014. ALBERTO PIZZOLI/AFP/Getty Images

Sanjay Gupta to add more stars to upcoming Bollywood film Jazbaa’s cast

IANS Mumbai  – Filmmaker Sanjay Gupta is excited about the way his next project Jazbaa, starring Aishwarya Rai, Irrfan Khan and Anupam Kher, is shaping…
Continue Reading »

Indian Bollywood film actress Priyanka Chopra poses during a promotional event of the Tata Salt 'Maine Desh ka Namak Khaya Hai' campaign, which features the story of boxer Mary Kom, and the promotion of the film 'Mary Kom' in Mumbai on September 10, 2014. AFP PHOTOSTR/AFP/Getty Images

Priyanka Chopra accepts Hrithik Roshan’s dare, performs handstand in heels

IANS Mumbai — Priyanka Chopra accepted and performed a handstand with a push up – a dare thrown at her by Hrithik Roshan. “The only…
Continue Reading »