Sikhs divided over whether Surrey temple executives should be baptized believers only

Published: November 14, 2012

Worshippers attend the Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara Temple on 120th Street in Surrey, B.C. May 30, 2012. Ric Ernst/PNG


A serious division remains at the Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara in Surrey over whether temple executive committee membership should be restricted to baptized believers only.

The B.C. Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal of Justice Laura Gerow’s decision to invalidate the passing of a controversial resolution, put forward at a temple meeting in June 2011, to restrict executive committee membership to baptized Sikhs only.

The B.C. Supreme Court judge found inadequate notice was given to the congregation’s 30,000 or so members concerning the proposed amendment.

To be a member of Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara, one of North America’s largest Sikh temples, one must be at least 18 years old, a Canadian citizen or landed immigrant, live in Surrey, Delta or White Rock, and, of course, believe in Sikhism.

In November 2009, the temple’s current executive, known as the Sikh Youth Executive, was elected. All members of that slate are baptized.

More than 20,000 of the temple society’s membership – a majority of them are not baptized – voted in that election.

In June 2011, there was a meeting where a number of resolutions to amend the temple society’s bylaws were presented, one of which was to limit membership to the executive to the baptized only.

“There is no issue that this is a significant change to the bylaws and would result in the majority of the members of the society being ineligible to run for election for the executive,” Gerow noted in January, after the matter went to court.

Gerow nixed the resolution, finding that inadequate notice was given to members about the vote. In setting the resolution aside, she noted that a society cannot pass bylaws that violate the Society Act.

The judge stated in her reasons for decision that she believes “the court has no role is a religious debate” but added that “given the divisiveness of the issue, it is my view that it is also appropriate to order that any proper amendment to the qualifications for designated offices be overseen by an independent observer.”

Gerow’s decision to invalidate the resolution was appealed. On Nov. 2, Justice John Hall, of B.C.’s appeal court, upheld Gerow’s decision following a court hearing in Vancouver.

“This case appears to involve at its heart a controversy between what might be termed certain of the ‘old guard’ members of the society and some younger members,” Hall observed.

Hall did, however, question her order that an independent observer should oversee any future vote on this resolution.

“Such an order immediately raises the query of how the term ‘independent’ should be construed,” Hall stated in his reasons for decision. “One party’s ‘independent observer’ might be considered highly biased by another party. If an order of this sort is to be made, I consider it could only be made after a process wherein respective parties put forward suggestions as to who might properly be chosen to undertake such a function.

“By such procedure,” Hall said, “a court would be enabled to properly assess who might be appointed to perform such a function. I venture to observe that if proper notice of a meeting were to be afforded to members of the society and a transparent methodology adopted for conduct of a meeting, no ‘observer’ should be required.”

For more Surrey news, visit Surrey Now.



Spice Radio calling on Metro Vancouver to Raise Your Hands Against Racism Saturday

VANCOUVER DESI Burnaby-based broadcaster Spice Radio is asking community members across Metro Vancouver to raise their hands against racism on Saturday. As part of the…
Continue Reading »

brutal DELHI gang rape

CBC to air controversial documentary about Indian gang rape

THE CANADIAN PRESS TORONTO — A documentary that the Indian government tried to ban from broadcast is getting airtime in Canada on Sunday. “India’s Daughter”…
Continue Reading »


YouTube blocks access to BBC documentary ‘India’s Daughter’, Indian government serves legal notice

  IANS New Delhi – YouTube on Thursday began blocking access to the controversial BBC documentary on the December 16, 2012 gang rape, citing court…
Continue Reading »


Today in History – March 16

Advance THE CANADIAN PRESS Today in History for March 16: On this date: In AD 37, Roman emperor Tiberius died. He was succeeded by Caligula….
Continue Reading »

Today in History – March 18

Advance THE CANADIAN PRESS Today in History for March 18: On this date: In 1314, 39 Knights Templar were burned at the stake in Paris….
Continue Reading »

Today in History – March 20

Advance THE CANADIAN PRESS Today in History for March 20: On this date: In 1413, England’s King Henry IV died; he was succeeded by Henry…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...


Gallery: Eight-year-old ‘Little Money, Big Difference’ campaign goes viral

VANCOUVER DESI Eight years ago, Cordaid People in Need, a development aid organization launched its campaign ‘Little Money, Big Difference’ to draw attention to the fact that…
Continue Reading »

Hands Against Racism

Hands Against Racism: Send us a selfie and make a statement against racism (with video)

VANCOUVER DESI Vancouver Desi’s digital anti-racism campaign, Raise Your Hands Against Racism, officially kicked off Thursday, with people across the Lower Mainland sending in selfies…
Continue Reading »


Canada-wide initiative helps immigrants find work in fields for which they have prepared

LARISSA CAHUTE VANCOUVER DESI When Manbir Randhawa immigrated from India to B.C., she knew she’d have to “start from scratch” in order to land a…
Continue Reading »

Desi-weird news

Doctor’s afraid to release baby who ‘spontaneously combusted’ to his mom

VANCOUVER DESI Doctors in India are reluctant to release a baby who ‘spontaneously combusted’ to his mom, fearing she suffers from an attention-seeking syndrome, Britain’s…
Continue Reading »

Surrey farm-food bank BC

Volunteers rally in support of God’s Little Acre Farm after food banks refuse donations

JENNIFER SALTMAN VANCOUVER DESI Volunteers are rallying around a philanthropic Surrey farmer after local food banks refused to accept his food donations and questioned his…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood Latest


Second Best Exotic Marigold Hotel welcomes back Lillete Dubey

John Madden film also stars Richard Gere BOB THOMPSON POSTMEDIA NEWS LONDON — Lillete Dubey has appeared in more than 40 films, many of them…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood actress Priyanka Chopra missing home on Holi, busy with ABC drama in Atlanta

IANS Mumbai – With Holi on Friday, actress-singer Priyanka Chopra says she misses being at home on the festival of colours. The actress took to…
Continue Reading »

Kingfisher calendar

Kingfisher calendar girl Sarah Jane Dias to make her debut in live performance

IANS Mumbai – Indie singer Sarah Jane Dias is set to perform in front of a live audience for the first time with the ‘The…
Continue Reading »