Real-estate developer allowed to withdraw guilty plea in fraud case, judge rules

Published: February 28, 2014

Tarsem Gill leaves BC Supreme Court in Vancouver, BC., January 9, 2014. Nick Procaylo/PNG

KEITH FRASER
VANCOUVER DESI

A judge has allowed former Vancouver real estate developer Tarsem Singh Gill to withdraw his guilty pleas in connection with a $40-million mortgage fraud.

In a ruling Friday, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Terry Schultes said that the possibility of a “miscarriage of justice” loomed large if he denied Gill’s application to withdraw his pleas to two counts of fraud.

It’s the latest twist in one of B.C.’s longest-running criminal cases.

Gill has had five lawyers and five trial dates since the charges were laid against him in 2008. That followed a six-year police investigation into a fraudulent scheme involving dozens of home purchases dating back more than 12 years.

Kevin McCullough, Gill’s latest lawyer, argued that his client was depressed and anxious at the time he entered the guilty pleas last May.

And he said Gill was not admitting to the essential elements of the offences to which he had pleaded guilty.

Prosecutor Kevin Gillett argued that Gill’s pleas were a straightforward acceptance of the basic elements of the offence, put in a simple form.

He said that evidence from a psychologist about Gill’s mental state was at odds with Gill’s own evidence during the court application.

But the judge said despite inconsistencies about the evidence of Gill’s depression, the evidence of his wife and friends about his depression at the time of the pleas was unchallenged.

His claim not to have admitted the necessary intent for fraud at the time of his guilty pleas was circumstantially supported and there was a “meaningful concern” about the validity of the pleas, the judge concluded.

“The possiblity of a miscarriage of justice looms large if Mr. Gill were to be held to the pleas.”

The case will next be before the courts March 7 to set a date for trial.

Gill’s co-accused, former lawyer Martin Wirick, pleaded guilty in June 2009 and received a seven-year jail term. He was also disbarred. The scam involved the biggest legal fraud in Canadian history.

During Wirick’s sentencing, court heard that Wirick acted as Gill’s solicitor and that from 1999 to 2002 misdirected money from Gill-related real estate transactions.

Instead of paying off mortgages and liens on properties that unsuspecting people thought they were buying, Wirick funnelled the money to Gill or his numbered companies. The mortgages on the homes remained. The owners of 77 properties were affected.

Related stories:

kfraser@theprovince.com
twitter.com/keithrfraser


Tags: , , , , , , , , ,





Featured

gay marriage-fake-scam

Undercover agent ‘Ruby’ from Mumbai exposes fake gay marriage scam in UK

HINDUSTAN TIMES A new crime sub-category has emerged in Britain after same-sex marriages were made legal in March: fake marriages between same-sex couples for a…
Continue Reading »

crime-BC

Abbotsford police don’t think missing girl was abducted or hurt

VIVIAN LUK THE CANADIAN PRESS ABBOTSFORD, B.C. — Police in Abbotsford were cautiously optimistic Wednesday morning that a report of a missing young girl is…
Continue Reading »

B.C. courts

Not recognizing marital rape in India as an offence is hypocrisy in law, judge says

IANS New Delhi – Observing that India is yet to recognize woman’s right to control marital intercourse as a core component of equality, a court…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

3 Afghan soldiers who fled for Canada fear torture, death if they return home

By Carolyn Thompson THE ASSOCIATED PRESS BATAVIA, N.Y. — Three Afghan military officers who sought refuge in Canada after taking off from a military training…
Continue Reading »

3 Afghan soldiers who fled for Canada fear torture, death if they return home

By Carolyn Thompson THE ASSOCIATED PRESS BATAVIA, N.Y. — Three Afghan military officers who sought refuge in Canada after taking off from a military training…
Continue Reading »

B.C. reports two enterovirus cases in child and teen with polio-like symptoms

By Sheryl Ubelacker THE CANADIAN PRESS TORONTO — A new threat is emerging in the outbreak of the respiratory illness enterovirus D68 — a small…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

drug-chemical-ban-India

Health Canada bans some drugs from India on quality concerns

THE CANADIAN PRESS OTTAWA — Health Canada says it is banning imports of some medications and drug ingredients produced in India due to concerns about…
Continue Reading »

DINNER WHITE HOUSE

What’s on the White House menu for Indian PM Narendra Modi who’s fasting?

CONNIE CASS THE ASSOCIATED PRESS WASHINGTON — What do you serve a man who isn’t eating? Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi was served warm water…
Continue Reading »

dog-rock-tar

Video: Rescue story of a dog that fell into hot tar and turned into a rock

VANCOUVER DESI A team of animal rescuers in Western India spent two days working to free a helpless dog trapped in a pile of hot…
Continue Reading »

body image-beauty-weight-control

Self-compassion leads to positive body image in women

IANS Toronto – Women who accept and tolerate their bodily imperfections appear to have a more positive body image despite their high body mass index…
Continue Reading »

1PNG_0929N_CITY_INQUEST_218232808

Close the Vancouver airport immigration cells where Mexican woman hanged herself: lawyer

SUSAN LAZARUK VANCOUVER DESI Canada should close the immigration holding centre where a Mexican woman awaiting deportation hanged herself, and put up detainees in hotels,…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

Priyanka Chopra

Gallery: Bollywood celebs — then and now

VANCOUVER DESI We are loyal Bollywood fans and have followed our favourites through the years, be it the Khans or the beauty queens. Here’s a…
Continue Reading »

BOLLYWOOD

Haider: A powerful revenge saga (w/trailer)

TROY RIBEIRO IANS  Film: “Haider”; Cast: Shahid Kapoor, Tabu, Kay Kay Menon, Shraddha Kapoor, Irrfan Khan; Director: Vishal Bhardwaj; Rating: *** 1/2) With revenge as…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood

Hrithik Roshan: Adversity is a gym for the mind

RASHIKA BHIRANI IANS  New Delhi – He overcame stammering; witnessed his father’s failure as an actor and producer and his surviving a gunshot wound; saw…
Continue Reading »