Surrey mother still can’t convince immigration officials her marriage is the real thing

Published: July 10, 2014


Picture 1 of 7

L to R: Harpreet Singh, daughter Kashvi and Harpreet Sandhu together in India. Sandhu has been fighting to get her husband Canadian residency for four years. Submitted photo.

LARISSA CAHUTE
VANCOUVER DESI

Harpreet Sandhu just wants her family to be “complete” with her husband, two-year-old daughter and baby on the way together in Surrey.

But instead, her husband, Harpreet Singh, is a world away in India, while she lives at her parents’ Surrey home, raising her daughter Kashvi alone, terrified this will only continue once the baby arrives in September.

Since she married in June 2010, Sandhu has been fighting to bring her husband to Canada. But, appeal after appeal, Citizenship and Immigration Canada repeatedly denies their applications for sponsorship and permanent residency.

“It’s been hard,” Sandhu told Vancouver Desi on Wednesday. “I just need him here right now … it’s the second pregnancy and he needs to be here.”

Singh already missed the birth of Kashvi, his first child, as CIC denied him residency, claiming the marriage appeared “arranged in haste” and was “not genuine and was entered into primarily for the purpose of acquiring permanent residence in Canada,” which was originally reported by Vancouver Desi in October 2012.

Nearly two years later, Sandhu is still fighting — this time taking her case to Federal Court in August.

According to immigration consultant Mumtaz Khan, it’s “unusual” for a case like this to go on for so long, as most people can’t afford the costs of going to federal court. And while it’s cost well over $30,000 for Sandhu to carry on the case, “they haven’t given up,” he said.

The latest decision from the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada, dated February 2014 and obtained by Vancouver Desi, said that although the immigration minister’s counsel now “consented that the marriage was genuine,” the appeal was still dismissed because counsel believes “the primary purpose for the marriage was to acquire a status or privilege.”

“It’s just shocking that they accept that the marriage is genuine but they won’t let the couple be together,” said Khan.

“When you look at a marriage — even if it’s a love marriage — one looks at a number of factors.

“Of course (the fact she’s from Canada) is one of the factors when you look at arranged marriages, but this was not the only factor … that swayed them to kind of contract the marriage.”

“They (also) looked at education, family background, her Sikh religion.”

Khan chalks the situation up to the immigration board applying “the letter of the law” as opposed to “the spirit of the law.”

“If they looked at the spirit of the law, this young couple should have been reunited,” he said.

“This young woman is suffering, she’s bringing up the child as a single parent.”

In an attempt to keep her family together, Sandhu has been travelling back and forth to India — Kashvi in tow — where she’ll stay with her husband for about five months at a time.

She and her daughter just returned from their most recent trip in April, but due to Sandhu’s diabetes and how far along she is in her pregnancy she can’t return any time soon.

“It shouldn’t be like this,” said Sandhu. “I’m a Canadian, my daughter’s a Canadian, too.”

“She should have her father here and I should have my husband here. It should be all of us together in Canada — not him in India and us going there to visit him.”

Related:

lcahute@theprovince.com
twitter.com/larissacahute


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,





Featured

DEPORTED-PAKISTAN

Tearful farewell as woman who faces death for adultery charges in Pakistan deported from Saskatoon

EVAN RADFORD THE STARPHOENIX As Jamila Bibi embraced her ally and friend Sahana Yeasmin, she was whisked away at the Saskatoon airport by two Canadian…
Continue Reading »

Simian death-monkey god

Monkey gets Hindu cremation by Indian villagers to avoid misfortune

VANCOUVER DESI In a bizarre sequence of events, almost 200 youths shaved off their heads to ward off ‘ill omen’ brought on by the death…
Continue Reading »

desi gangster murder

Suspect in gangster Sandip Dhure shooting claims Charter rights violated when police seized firearms from apartments

KEITH FRASER, VANCOUVER DESI A Vancouver man who was a suspect in a high-profile gang-related shooting, and his co-accused, are claiming their rights were violated…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

Saskatoon woman, 65, deported to Pakistan after appeal to Federal Court rejected

THE CANADIAN PRESS TORONTO — A 65-year-old woman working as a cook in Saskatoon has been deported to her native Pakistan, where her lawyer says…
Continue Reading »

DEPORTED-PAKISTAN

Tearful farewell as woman who faces death for adultery charges in Pakistan deported from Saskatoon

EVAN RADFORD THE STARPHOENIX As Jamila Bibi embraced her ally and friend Sahana Yeasmin, she was whisked away at the Saskatoon airport by two Canadian…
Continue Reading »

desi gangster murder

Suspect in gangster Sandip Dhure shooting claims Charter rights violated when police seized firearms from apartments

KEITH FRASER, VANCOUVER DESI A Vancouver man who was a suspect in a high-profile gang-related shooting, and his co-accused, are claiming their rights were violated…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

Scroll Invitation

Wedding invitations – the Do’s

KIM TREHAN VANCOUVER DESI You are cordially invited…. We request the honor of your presence… Please join us… It is so difficult to decide on…
Continue Reading »

INDIA_ACID_ATTACKS_PHOTO_GALLERY_217739018

Acid-attacked teen, Laxmi, chosen to model for New Delhi’s India Runway Week

IANS New Delhi  – One of India’s young acid attack victims has been chosen to walk the runway at the third edition of India Runway…
Continue Reading »

CEN_MonkeyGod_01.jpg

ID card obtained in the name of India’s monkey god exposes corrupt system

CEN AGENCY An Indian computer programmer has managed to get an official identity card in the name of India’s monkey god after bribing corrupt officials….
Continue Reading »

girl child

Upset over having two daughters and no son, man bobbitises himself

IANS Patna – A man in Bihar has bobbitised himself, sniping off his penis with a sharp knife in a fit of rage after a…
Continue Reading »

heptathlete India

Indian athlete with six toes on each foot attempts to overcome deformity to medal at Asian Games

C. RAJSHEKHAR RAO THE ASSOCIATED PRESS NEW DELHI – Merely wearing shoes is painful for Swapna Barman. She was born with six toes on each…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

hot photos desi actress bollywood sex

Deepika Padukone: I have breasts, you got a problem?

VANCOUVER DESI Bollywood actress Deepika Padukone has caused a social media storm over her ‘cleavage show’ story in a leading Indian news outlet. Padukone slammed…
Continue Reading »

Dr Cabbie

Canadian actor Vinay Virmani’s Dr. Cabbie continues his examination of South Asian immigrant experience

ALMAS MEHERALLY VANCOUVER DESI Toronto-born actor and writer Vinay Virmani is excited about his latest film, Dr. Cabbie, set to release in Canada on September…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood actress

Bollywood actress Shilpa Shetty says ‘I am a big solitaire fan’

IANS New Delhi – Bollywood actress-producer and entrepreneur Shilpa Shetty says she can’t step out without a piece of jewellery or accessory, especially a solitaire….
Continue Reading »