TAMILS: Vancouver judge quashes charges against four accused of people smuggling

Published: January 25, 2013

Tamils waving aboard the MV Ocean Lady in 2009. Four men charged with smuggling 76 Tamils aboard the ship have had their charges dismissed by a B.C. judge.

BY Keith Fraser
The Province
A B.C. judge who struck down Canada’s human smuggling law on Friday quashed the charges against four men accused of bringing 76 Tamils into Canada in 2009.
B.C. Supreme Court Justice Arne Silverman also suspended his declaration of invalidity of the law for 30 days so the federal Crown can go to the B.C. Court of Appeal and apply for a stay or further suspension of the ruling, pending a possible appeal.
The decisions by the judge followed his ruling on Jan. 11 that Section 117 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act was overbroad and unconstitutional.
Complicating the issue was the fact that the smuggling law was amended in December, prior to Silverman’s ruling.
The judge said he agreed with the Crown’s argument that the striking down of the law created a void in past prosecutions, including 95 criminal charges that were laid prior to the December amendment.
The Crown argued that the ruling meant authorities were powerless to deal with those past cases, leaving the public unprotected.
The judge said he had “great concern” about the void that was created and the need to protect the public, in light of the 95 cases, nine of which are in B.C.
He said if there was no suspension of the declaration of invalidity, there was a question about what might happen to the 95 accused.
“I’m concerned about whether or not they might be released into the community when arguably they should not be,” he said in brief reasons of judgment.
“Conversely, I also have concerns that persons should have to continue to face charges perhaps without bail when there is an existing decision which has struck down the section under which they are charged.”
The Crown and defence agreed that in the circumstances, the charges against the four accused should be quashed and the judge made that declaration.
The four men — Francis Anthonimuthu Appulonappa, Hamalraj Handasamy, Jeyachandran Kanagarajah and Vignarajah Thevarajah — are on bail and living in Ontario, where there is a large Tamil community. They weren’t in the Vancouver courtroom Friday.
All four men have filed refugee claims but those claims were suspended pending the outcome of the prosecution.
The men were arrested after the 76 Sri Lankan Tamils aboard the ship came in off the coast of B.C. in 2009.
Silverman’s ruling is also expected to impact the case of six men charged with smuggling 492 Tamils aboard the MV Sun Sea in 2010. That prosecution was scheduled to follow the MV Ocean Lady case.
In his ruling striking down the law, the judge said that the law captures categories of persons — including humanitarian workers and close family members of refugees — who the Crown did not intend to prosecute.
He said the law had a legitimate objective — to prosecute the crime of human smuggling — but agreed with the defence that it was too sweeping and violated the accused’s right to life, liberty and security of person.
It is anticipated that the case will eventually wind up in the Supreme Court of Canada, a process which could take several years.
kfraser@theprovince.com
twitter.com/keithrfraser






Featured

DESI-SURREY-BURNABY

B.C. wrestler awarded belated gold medal

VANCOUVER DESI Burnaby Central graduate Amar Dhesi has become the first Indo Canadian to win gold at the FILA Junior World Championships in freestyle wrestling….
Continue Reading »

Desi Sex

Australian political candidate fired for promoting Sunny Leone’s Melbourne tour (w/gallery)

VANCOUVER DESI A political candidate in Australia has been fired for his reported involvement in the promotions for Indo Canadian porn star Sunny Leone’s upcoming…
Continue Reading »

murder-British-India

South African judge will decide whether to throw out honeymoon murder case

CHRISTOPHER TORCHIA THE ASSOCIATED PRESS JOHANNESBURG — A South African judge will rule Dec. 8 on whether to dismiss the murder case against a British…
Continue Reading »

LOCAL NEWS

DESI-SURREY-BURNABY

B.C. wrestler awarded belated gold medal

VANCOUVER DESI Burnaby Central graduate Amar Dhesi has become the first Indo Canadian to win gold at the FILA Junior World Championships in freestyle wrestling….
Continue Reading »

ParkerWiggins

Spice Sports: Top 2 NBA Draft Picks go Head-to-Head!

GOPI AND THE GORA FOR VANCOUVER DESI TUNE IN TO SPICE SPORTS, M-F, 5-7PM ON SPICE RADIO 1200AM Last night, for the first time this…
Continue Reading »

Desi Sex

Australian political candidate fired for promoting Sunny Leone’s Melbourne tour (w/gallery)

VANCOUVER DESI A political candidate in Australia has been fired for his reported involvement in the promotions for Indo Canadian porn star Sunny Leone’s upcoming…
Continue Reading »

Don't Miss...

NDP Minister

Editorial: Amrik Virk should do the honourable thing and resign

THE PROVINCE If Advanced Education Minister and former Mountie Amrik Virk doesn’t understand why he should resign his portfolio, Premier Christy Clark should ease him…
Continue Reading »

murder-suicide

Girls hanged from tree died by suicide, say Indian investigators who ruled out gang rape

MUNEEZA NAQVI THE ASSOCIATED PRESS NEW DELHI — India’s top investigative agency said Thursday that two teenage girls believed to have been raped and hanged…
Continue Reading »

Surrey crash-desi

Surrey crash victim’s son says deporting parolee would ‘send a message’

TOM ZYTARUK SURREY NOW SURREY — A Surrey man who killed an elderly man when he smashed his brother’s Corvette into a Surrey bus shelter…
Continue Reading »

Islamophobia

Stereotyping is alive and well when it comes to Muslim and Sikh religious symbols in Canada

GORDON MCINTYRE VANCOUVER DESI One-third of British Columbians believe radicalized people live among us, according to a poll commissioned by The Province. The survey of…
Continue Reading »

TANDOORI KINGS OF COMEDY

Abbotsford comics’ bid for TV show doesn’t make the cut

VANCOUVER DESI After more than a month of contest challenges and video production, two Abbotsford comedians’ pitch for a cross-cultural comedy show will not be…
Continue Reading »


Bollywood Latest

Desi Sex

Australian political candidate fired for promoting Sunny Leone’s Melbourne tour (w/gallery)

VANCOUVER DESI A political candidate in Australia has been fired for his reported involvement in the promotions for Indo Canadian porn star Sunny Leone’s upcoming…
Continue Reading »

Veena Malik

Bollywood actress Veena Malik’s five top controversies before blasphemy charges

HINDUSTAN TIMES Controversy seems to be Veena Malik’s second name. As she accepted herself in an interview to Hindustan Times a few years back, it…
Continue Reading »

Bollywood sex

Sonam Kapoor: Bollywood’s ‘hungry young woman’

IANS New Delhi – Actress Sonam Kapoor seems to have taken inspiration from Bollywood’s angry young man title, but with a twist. The actress has…
Continue Reading »